• barsquid@lemmy.worldEnglish
    431·
    16 days ago

    He wants a marketplace of ideas? Not a centrally planned economy of ideas? And Hexbear isn’t calling him a far-right radical?

    • TheFriar@lemm.eeEnglish
      19·
      16 days ago

      I mean…every time I challenge a tankie and I didn’t realize I was in a tankie instance, I get deleted and banned.

      • goat@sh.itjust.worksOPMEnglish
        6·
        16 days ago

        That’s normally how it goes. Turns out their views don’t actually hold up to scrutiny.

  • Cheradenine@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
    234·
    16 days ago

    Isn’t that hexbear? If so, they defederated from sh.itjust.works because we’re big meanies, or something

  • BonerMan@ani.socialEnglish
    181·
    16 days ago

    Driving down the road and complaining that everyone is a wrong way driver…

    The irony is outstanding.

  • LibertyLizard@slrpnk.netEnglish
    17·
    16 days ago

    I mean all of Lemmy is an echo chamber of one kind or another. Although there are certainly varying degrees. I don’t know anything about Hexbear but lemm.ml is the worst I’ve seen due to the heavy-handed behavior of the admins.

      • DragonTypeWyvern@midwest.socialEnglish
        61·
        16 days ago

        Hexbear can be funny in small doses, .ml is more seriousposting.

        Either way they’re best experienced from a distance.

        • Zetta@mander.xyzEnglish
          51·
          16 days ago

          Ya hexbear is fun to browse. You can’t even dislike comments or posts so it feels less negative lol

            • Zetta@mander.xyzEnglish
              2·
              16 days ago

              Haha probably, but enough matter what it’s actually sorta fun being able to say whatever and have a conversation with them without getting down voted obscenely.

      • LibertyLizard@slrpnk.netEnglish
        4·
        16 days ago

        While I wouldn’t say I like the instance users I do get some value from engaging with tankies, personally. They have a unique perspective and it motivates me to learn more about aspects history and politics that are not always discussed by other groups of people.

        The big problem is that I’m not allowed to correct their misinformation. This makes honest discussions and learning impossible on the .ml instance. Since my instance is defederated from grad and Hexbear I have little knowledge of their space. When you say I wouldn’t like it, is that due to the users or due to the way the space is moderated? Can I go to these spaces and offer a respectful dissenting viewpoint? Personally I find that to be a very significant distinction. I don’t mind being the bearer of unpopular truths—in fact it gives me a certain satisfaction. But I will not tolerate spaces where the truth is completely silenced.

        • sugar_in_your_tea@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
          8·
          16 days ago

          Can I go to these spaces and offer a respectful dissenting viewpoint?

          No, you’ll likely get banned.

          I also appreciate alternative perspectives, especially if they can back it up with solid sources. I’ve consistently pushed against defederation on my own instance because I think seeing their posts has value. However, in many cases they’ll brigade posts to drown out topics they don’t like, or if it’s on their instance, they’ll push for the users to get banned.

          • LibertyLizard@slrpnk.netEnglish
            5·
            16 days ago

            Unfortunately that kind of behavior from users is common on pretty much every instance from what I’ve seen. Just go to Lemmy.world and try to criticize Kamala Harris and see how it goes.

            But from what I’ve seen the admins and mods there and on most other instances (usually) take a more measured hand and only ban when necessary, while frank discussion of Chinese history on Lemmy.ml is equated with racism and will get you an immediate ban from the entire instance.

            That’s why I, even as a non-tankie leftist, prefer these spaces even though many tankies will claim they’re overrun with liberals. I still disagree with a lot of the conventional wisdom there, but I’m allowed to express that dissent and discuss any topic I wish to in a respectful way, which I think helps me and other people understand these contentious issues more fully and accurately.

            • sugar_in_your_tea@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
              51·
              16 days ago

              Just go to Lemmy.world and try to criticize Kamala Harris and see how it goes.

              I’m sure I have. I don’t pay close attention to which instances I post on, and I’ve certainly criticized Kamala Harris, perhaps more than Donald Trump, because there are so many posts from people who are obviously on Harris’ camp spreading disinformation and very few in the opposite direction.

              Don’t get me wrong though, I despise Trump and believe he will be worse for our country than Harris, I just disagree that Harris is “good” in any sense of the word. She’s mediocre at best, and was dead last on my preferred list of presidential candidates in 2016 for the Democratic Party and Biden wasn’t much higher (Trump was dead last for me on the Republican side). My state is going to elect Trump, regardless of how I vote, so I’m voting third party to signal that I’m unsatisfied with either option. I voted for Biden last election though, because I thought he had a chance of flipping my state (I’m in Utah, and people here generally dislike Trump). But no, he lost by ~20% like most elections here, and Harris is even less likeable than Biden.

              I, even as a non-tankie leftist

              For reference, I’m a left-leaning libertarian. I support things like UBI/NIT, with the argument that it’s better than our overly complicated welfare system, which is hard for the people who need the benefits the most to actually use. I’m less motivated by “taxation is theft” and more motivated by “less is more” when it comes to government (i.e. I’m fine raising taxes, if it means government services are less complex/subjective).

              So maybe I’m a bit less welcome than you, because I tend to push back on the general idea of “more government = better,” which seems to be pretty common among “tankies,” and I’m generally pretty skeptical of government in general. That said, I tend to restrict discussion to things we may be able to make progress on (i.e. UBI/NIT, abortion policy, etc), but even then I get a lot of pushback because I don’t agree with the underlying assumption that government is good.

    • goat@sh.itjust.worksOPMEnglish
      4·
      16 days ago

      Thankfully this community isn’t an echo chamber. Tankies are more than welcome to talk about communism and capitalism, so long as they don’t start encouraging or justifying violence.